Contact Me

Email: bawriting@earthlink.net
Phone: 562 628-9688

My Blog Archives


My Facebook Page

Get My News


Get My RSS Feed





Chapter 12: Is Anybody There?

Milly is having her mid-life crisis: her teenage children are making her crazy, her husband is too busy and exhausted by his aerospace job to pay enough attention to her, the circle’s quarreling is stressing her out, and the Goddess seems to have deserted her. She seeks sympathy from Rachel, solace from Joe, and advice from Brooke. Finally, the old women give her a reality check.

  • The chapter title is from a song in the musical 1776. When all the other delegates walk out of the Continental Congress, John Adams is left alone on stage. In despair, he asks, “Is anybody there? Does anybody care?” I think we’ve all had that feeling.
  • It is useful to see that witches lead normal lives with family turmoil and all the other stuff that regular people encounter in life. We see that Milly’s husband, though busy, does love her and understands the circle and the Goddess.
  • Huxtables. The all-American family of The Cosby Show, a sitcom that led the TV ratings from 1984 to 1992.
  • Yes, the route Milly takes from Fountain Valley to Belmont Shore is the most direct route on surface streets. I’ve driven it many times. Yes, it’s often faster than the freeways.
  • We first met Joe in chapter 7. He will reappear in chapter 16. He’s another sympathetic male character. Nowadays, alas, independent bookstores like his are almost extinct. Billy Joel’s An Innocent Man was released in 1984. Joe knows all the words to all the songs. That’s what makes him the coolest guy in the book.
  • Dick works for McDonnell Douglas, a major aerospace and defense corporation that was founded in 1967 and merged with (was bought out by) Boeing in 1997. In addition to jet airplanes, they built Skylab, which turned into the Space lab, which turned into the Space Station. I have a friend who worked at the company’s facility in Huntington Beach until he retired. He held a Top Secret clearance and used to joke, “If I told you what I do, I’d have to kill you.”
  • As Brooke comforts and advises Milly here, so will Milly comfort and advise Brooke as she tries to come to terms with her feelings about Matthew (chapter 19).
  • Every woman is a priestess at her own altar. This was a common cliché then and maybe still is now. Generally speaking, neopagans and witches tend to be individualists and like to do things (including magical work) their way.
  • Romantic poetry. Joe is reading Wordsworth, Blake, Shelley, Byron, and that bunch, not lowercase romantic poetry. He’s better educated than he acts.
  • Milly at her altar. As my friend Ariadne Frye reminded me, it is important that we do our inner work. It’s fun to have all the tchotchkes, and the women in this book love their tchotchkes, but the true work is the inner work, done in our imaginations and our hearts. We can, that is to say, do magical work without a single candle or prop. Many neopagans I know have constructed their own inner temples. The most famous literary examples of the inner temple are in Dion Fortune’s novels, The Sea Priestess (first published in 1938) and Moon Magic (first published in 1956). (Amazon is selling way newer editions than the ones on my shelves.)
  • Everyone I have ever had a serious talk with has admitted that sometimes the Goddess just doesn’t seem to be present.
  • We all need to learn what Milly learns at the end. The Goddess manifests as She will, not as we will. As my teacher, Dagmola Jamyang Sakya, once told me, we often find Her in our friends. We can also occasionally glimpse Her when we look into an ordinary mirror.
Discussion questions:
  1. Should Milly and Joe feel guilty? Why or why not?
  2. In what ways is your life normal and/or typical and/or average? How is it different?
  3. Have you been through your own dark night or mid-life crisis? What was it like? If you haven’t been there yet, what do you expect?

Copyright © 2011 by Barbara Ardinger, Ph.D. All rights reserved. Permission granted to print this page of the Secret Lives Reader’s Guide for personal use only.